Trying to decide between real wood floors and something more budget-friendly? If you’re stuck on wood flooring vs engineered wood floor options, you’re not alone. The difference between solid hardwood flooring and engineered wood flooring isn’t always obvious at first glance, but it definitely matters. From durability and water resistance to cost and installation, each one has its perks. Let’s break it all down so you can pick the best flooring for your space, your lifestyle, and your budget. If you need new wood flooring for your home, we serve the entire Sacramento area, including Roseville and Folsom, with home remodeling and general contracting.
Paint Before or After Flooring?
Wood Floor vs Engineered Wood Floor
Engineered hardwood and solid hardwood are both top-tier flooring options made from real wood. They offer a natural beauty that fake wood floors like laminate or vinyl just can’t match. At first glance, they look the same, but the differences start just below the surface.
Engineered hardwood has a thin layer of hardwood on top of strong plywood. That design makes it more affordable than solid wood. Solid hardwood, on the other hand, is made from one solid piece, which is usually oak, maple, or walnut. It’s tougher, lasts longer, and can be refinished more times over its life.
The biggest difference is the core, and that matters for water resistance. Neither option is great for bathrooms. Kitchens are a maybe, but it depends on how much water and spills the floor might face.
Pros and Cons of Both
Engineered Hardwood
Pros:
- Looks just like solid hardwood
- Usually more affordable
- More stable in humid environments
- Easier to install (can be floated or glued)
- Often better for basements or concrete subfloors
Cons:
- Can only be refinished once or twice
- Not as long-lasting as solid wood
- Still not great with heavy water exposure
- Quality varies by brand and thickness
Solid Hardwood
Pros:
- Made from solid wood throughout
- Extremely durable and long-lasting
- Can be refinished many times
- Adds strong resale value to homes
- Timeless, classic appearance
Cons:
- More expensive upfront
- Prone to expanding or shrinking with humidity
- Installation is harder and usually nailed down
- Not ideal for bathrooms or damp areas
Which is More Durable?
Solid hardwood holds up better over time because it’s one thick piece of wood. It can take more wear and tear and still be sanded down and refinished multiple times. That gives it a longer life, especially in high-traffic areas.
Which Lasts Longer?
Solid hardwood usually lasts longer because it can handle more refinishing over the years. Even after decades, it can be sanded down and refreshed to look like new. Engineered wood has a thinner top layer, so once it wears down, it can’t be refinished as many times.
Which is Easier to Clean?
Both engineered and solid hardwood are easy to clean, but engineered hardwood has a slight edge. Its factory-finished surface is often more resistant to stains and moisture. That makes it easier to wipe up spills without damage, especially in busy households.
Which is More Soundproof?
Solid hardwood is generally more soundproof than engineered hardwood. Its dense, solid construction helps block and absorb sound better. Engineered wood has a layered core that can create more echo or noise, especially if not installed with a quality underlayment.
Which is Better For the Environment?
Engineered hardwood is often considered better for the environment because it uses less solid wood overall. Its plywood core is made from fast-growing, renewable wood species, which helps conserve slow-growing hardwoods like oak or walnut. It also produces less waste during manufacturing, making it a more resource-efficient option.
Is Engineered or Solid Hardwood Better for Homes with Pets?
If you have pets, your floors need to stand up to scratches, messes, and constant movement. Between engineered and solid hardwood, engineered tends to hold up better in a pet-friendly home. That’s mostly because of its durable factory-applied finishes, which can be more resistant to claw marks and surface wear.
Engineered wood is also less likely to expand or shrink when things get wet. That’s helpful if you’re cleaning up spilled water bowls, accidents, or muddy paw prints. Its layered construction gives it more stability, which means fewer problems with warping over time.
Solid hardwood can still work with pets, but it’s a bit more high-maintenance. You’ll want to choose harder species like oak or hickory and keep area rugs in play zones. It’s also more vulnerable to scratches and moisture, so you’ll need to stay on top of cleaning to keep it looking good.
What is the Average Lifespan of Engineered Wood Flooring
The average lifespan of engineered wood flooring typically ranges from 20 to 30 years, but it can last even longer with proper care. The key factor is the thickness of the top veneer layer. Thicker veneers allow for light sanding and refinishing, which can help extend the life of the floor when it starts to show wear.
Daily habits also play a role in how long your engineered floors will hold up. Using furniture pads, keeping floors clean, and avoiding standing water can make a big difference. Homes with lighter foot traffic may see engineered floors last decades without needing major touch-ups, while busier spaces might show signs of aging sooner.
What is the Average Lifespan of Solid Wood Flooring
Solid wood flooring is known for its impressive lifespan, often lasting 50 years or more. In many older homes, the original hardwood floors are still in place, proof of just how long they can endure when taken care of properly. As mentioned earlier, one reason solid hardwood lasts so long is that it can be sanded and refinished multiple times over the years. That means even if it gets scratched, dull, or worn down, you can refresh the surface and keep it looking like new. With routine maintenance and occasional refinishing, solid wood floors can easily outlast most other flooring types.
Best Brands for Engineered Hardwood
-
Mohawk
Mohawk is one of the largest and most trusted flooring brands in the U.S. Their engineered hardwood lines are known for durability, style variety, and eco-friendly practices. Mohawk uses a special finish called “ArmorMax” that adds extra protection against wear and stains. They also focus on sustainability, using recycled and responsibly sourced materials.
-
Shaw
Shaw offers a wide range of engineered hardwood products with beautiful finishes and trendy styles. They’re especially popular for their scratch-resistant coatings, which make them ideal for homes with kids or pets. Shaw floors are also designed with stability in mind, making them a solid choice for areas with changing humidity.
-
Anderson Tuftex
A premium brand under Shaw, Anderson Tuftex blends craftsmanship with style. Their engineered hardwoods often feature wide planks, hand-scraped textures, and rich stains. What sets them apart is their attention to detail. They handcraft many of their products for a more natural, luxurious look.
-
Bruce
Known for affordability and availability, Bruce offers both engineered and solid hardwood. Their engineered lines are easy to install and come in a wide selection of traditional wood tones. Bruce is a go-to for homeowners looking for dependable, real wood flooring without the high price tag.
-
Mannington
Mannington’s engineered hardwood combines high style with great performance. They use advanced technologies like ScratchResist® coating, which adds serious toughness. Their floors are also made in the USA and often feature unique patterns and finishes you won’t find with other brands.
Best Brands for Solid Hardwood
-
Somerset
Somerset is a U.S.-based company that focuses on high-quality Appalachian hardwoods. Their solid wood floors are milled in Kentucky and are known for tight grain patterns and consistency. Somerset offers prefinished and unfinished options, and their products are durable enough for decades of wear.
-
Mullican
Mullican has a reputation for premium wood selection and expert milling. They harvest much of their lumber from the Appalachian region, known for strong and stable hardwoods. Mullican offers various thicknesses and wood species, giving homeowners flexibility based on their needs and budget.
-
Bellawood
Sold primarily through Lumber Liquidators (LL Flooring), Bellawood is a favorite for its 100-year warranty and rich finishes. Their solid hardwood flooring is prefinished with an aluminum oxide layer for added protection. Bellawood is a great pick for anyone who wants a luxurious look with serious longevity.
-
Bruce
Bruce also makes solid hardwood and is one of the most recognizable names in the industry. Their products are widely available, making them a convenient option. While more affordable than other premium brands, Bruce floors still hold up well over time and come in plenty of styles.
The Wood Floor vs Engineered Wood Floor Conclusion
Choosing between engineered and solid hardwood basically comes down to your lifestyle, budget, and the kind of space you’re working with. Each option has its strengths, whether you’re after long-term durability, better moisture resistance, or just want something that fits your home’s style and needs.
If you’re in the Sacramento area and thinking about new flooring or planning a remodel, reach out to our team at LNL Construction. We handle everything from design to installation and take pride in delivering quality work that fits your vision.
Tags: wood floor vs engineered wood floor
